Reedsy
Reviews and Complaints
Reedsy Overview
The aggregated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
Reedsy has 2.6 star rating based on 13 customer reviews. Consumers are mostly neutral.
- Rating Distribution
Pros: No pros, Reasonabe prices, Reedsy encourages self publishing.
Cons: Are biased towards their professionals rather than clients, Do not screen the writers, Have no escalation services for disputes.Recent recommendations regarding this business are as follows: "Don’t bother with Reedsy. It’s with hiring an agent unless you have an editor who is happy to communicate and address your needs and questions rapidly. Ask for multiple references.", "Not sure as of now, but if this is something that happens a lot, I would say start away", "There may be some good editors there, but do your due dilligence. Push for more info on who you hire.", "ChatGPT is free!", "Keep away from Reedsy platform, consider ChatGPT as an option!".
The aggregated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
Reedsy has 2.6 star rating based on 13 customer reviews. Consumers are mostly neutral.
- Rating Distribution
Pros: No pros, Reasonabe prices, Reedsy encourages self publishing.
Cons: Are biased towards their professionals rather than clients, Do not screen the writers, Have no escalation services for disputes.Recent recommendations regarding this business are as follows: "Don’t bother with Reedsy. It’s with hiring an agent unless you have an editor who is happy to communicate and address your needs and questions rapidly. Ask for multiple references.", "Not sure as of now, but if this is something that happens a lot, I would say start away", "There may be some good editors there, but do your due dilligence. Push for more info on who you hire.", "ChatGPT is free!", "Keep away from Reedsy platform, consider ChatGPT as an option!".
Most users ask Reedsy for the refund as a solution to their issues.
Review authors value the most Diversity of Products or Services and Website. Consumers are not pleased with Exchange, Refund and Cancellation Policy and Billing Practices. The price level of this organization is high according to consumer reviews.
Media from reviews

Editor lied and published his own book instead while taking the money
Avoid Howard Lovy like the plague
He posts pro Israel stuff daily for an hour on X (I know, right?) and is on the board of the international self publishing guild.
Podcaster
Acted like deadlines didnt matter. Refused to answer basic questions.
After 7 months for a dang developmental edit (2 months is industry standard for this book length and it was a straight story biography) he said it was more like ghostwriting.
I wanted minimal readership and help marketing which he promised to do. I left plot points hanging to see what hed do or if hed catch name changes
He did not. I have over 10 years in the academic side of publishing. Ive never seen anything like Howard Lovy.
Hes out broadcasting about his own book and literally lied to me repeatedly or didnt answer basic questions when I asked him for updates or concerns or really anything !
Heres Howard:
Me: deadline is getting closer, how ar things going?
Howard: oh you want to get going on this?
Ill steam line it.
Sends 10 pages of modestly re arranged words with spelling and grammatical errors
Me: returns approval in a day
Howard: never heard from again until I contacted the company a week before the deadline whether I should pay the last installment
I thought Id give us a little more time working together
Me: you are like 1/4 done in six months of editing.
Howard Im still committed to helping you.
Me: fires him on the spot in march- youre under contract, this is not a favor.contacts lawyer.
Howard (more lies and excuses). He didnt even have a publishing contract as a self publisher
He just took the advances and acted like he was gonna walk aaay when he felt like it.
Seriously.
Avoid Howard like the plague. He is the least honest religious person I have met in a long line of Bible thimpers who scream morality daily
Well.
User's recommendation: Don’t bother with Reedsy. It’s with hiring an agent unless you have an editor who is happy to communicate and address your needs and questions rapidly. Ask for multiple references.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerMy whole book vanished and They want to pay a dollar to get answers for why my book was taken suddenly from their site while I was working on it. SUCKS!!!!!!!!
I do not have the words for how I feel. They could restore the book and allow me to keep working on it. Starting over is not something I want to do, but I can since I have the first book if the same story.
User's recommendation: Not sure as of now, but if this is something that happens a lot, I would say start away
Paid $7,000 and got a 1 page edited synopsis that I initially wrote
Reedsy doesn't screen the persons proposing various services on their website. No refunds are offered! The quality of services provided is not acceptable!
User's recommendation: ChatGPT is free!
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerDisaster
Agreed on a fee and timescale with a ghostwriter for a 30,000-word short story. After 3 months and 4/6 instalments, the ghostwriter failed to deliver a single chapter based on my brief.
After asking Reedsy to step in and mediate a refund of 75% if not 100% since I had no usable content for my book, they ended up agreeing on a 60/40% refund in favour of their ghostwriter! I was dumbfounded! Zero usable content and £4k down financially!
I certainly would not recommend Reedsy, let alone trust them to look out for your best interests. You're better off using CHATGPT!
- Are biased towards their professionals rather than clients
- Very bad user interface for sharing and reviewing content
User's recommendation: Keep away from Reedsy platform, consider ChatGPT as an option!
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerVery bad editing experience
These editors are not vetted I promise you. I paid over $1000 to a copy editor Charlotte.
Her work was below par. My proofreader picked up 35 gramnat errors in each chapter at min after Charlotte's gave it back to me. Reedsy did nothing even after her admission she did not do the best job.
I deserved a full refund. I have to repay for editing and formatting because of them
RUN RUN RUN!!!
- No pros
- It is a con
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: RUN run run....
This review is written by an individual who has purchased the reviewed product/service and/or confirms being a paying customer of this company. Check our FAQ
Verified Buyer |This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |I DID NOT RECIEVE MY PRODUCT WHICH I PAID $12,844.88 FOR !!
I contracted with Ms Andrea Williams who was listed with Reedsy as a Writer and author to write my memoir back in February 2023. At first, we communicated weekly, which quickly changed to monthly communications due to the writer's other personal obligations.
I was assured that the project would be complete by August 2023. In August, she sent me four poorly written incomplete chapters and asked for an extension on the deadline. I agreed to extend the deadline to December 31, 2023. I explained to Ms Williams that I have serious health issues, and we must complete my memoir as soon as possible, she assured me that it would be completed by the end of the year.
When the end of the year came, Ms Williams asked for another extension until April 1, 2024, I reluctantly agreed. On March 30, I spoke with Ms Williams, who told me that the project was not complete, and that she would still need additional time. I said, "No" and that I wanted 8,000.00 dollars refunded to my account due to breach of contract. She agreed and said she would return the money by April 5, 2025.
I have not received a refund or any communication from Ms Williams.
To make the problems worse, Reedsy has marked the project as completed. I expect Reedsy to assist me in this matter as soon as possible.
- Reasonabe prices
- Do not screen the writers
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: Please be very careful; Reedsy does not seem to vet the people they list.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerUDAAP violation of abusive and deceptive practices of taking customers funds with no service given
I contacted Reedsy about their unfair business practices of debiting customers accounts, when no services are not provided. I attached my communique in my previous write up, evidencing no services provider by reedsy and Reedsy refused to resolve it, this transaction by reedsy is a UDAAP violation and people need to know not to do business with them. As they have no disputes and escalation department, they don’t answer disputes and they leave their customers disgruntled.
Unfortunately between the start date 10/31 to the end date 11/10. I had no draft or any work sent to me. Half way into the timeline was Nov 4th/ 5th. With nothing produced as indicated in my previous communiquevto Curtis, I was weary of quality of a haphazard job rushed.
Since nothing was produced and sent to me as as at Nov 6th, 2023. I knew I would not accept a last minute job, so I cancelled. You can clearly in all communiques which I have copies of, my fears about half hazard jobs. I am speaking for the last time, I need to be contacted by someone in your escalation team.
Or this will go viral, if I am being stopped and bullied into paying for no services despite my correspondences to You and Curtis timely about his posture, not to produce any services for me. If no body contacts me from your escalation department to resolve this. I will assume, that Reedsy responsive in resolvingvwhat would be termed a UDAAP violation and it will take another shift.
So, I suggest for the last time, that youvescalate it get back with me informing me who is working to resolve this matter, this is my final call! Thank you.
- Have no escalation services for disputes
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: It’s an unreliable freelancer site to do business with, I ordered services. Freelancer scheduled a 10 day turn around, by day 7 no draft, no documentation, no service offered. I escalated it, the representative Alex refused to escalate it and they debited me for NO SERVICES offered. Your better off using some reputable structured freelance service
This review is written by an individual who has purchased the reviewed product/service and/or confirms being a paying customer of this company. Check our FAQ
Verified Buyer |This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerThey will steal your money
Great place to drop $900 and get NOTHING in return. Their project protection is a complete joke.
Author refused to read the materials necessary to write my book, and made errors all over the place. They took $900 from me, and I received absolutely nothing in return.
- Took 900 dollars and i got nothing in return
Preferred solution: Apology
User's recommendation: Do NOT give them your money
Reedsy deleted feedback and evidence against them
After they failed to submit the project on time, they deleted my feedback (rather than responding to it) and any evidence on their bad service that may be used against them.
User's recommendation: Avoid Reedsy
Companies Similar to Reedsy
Thank You for Your Reply! We are processing your message.
Your comment is successfully posted.

Agreed!